Steel vs. Wood: Which Garage Door Material Is Best for Your Indiana Home?

April 13, 20252 min read

When it’s time to replace or install a new garage door, one of the biggest decisions you'll make is choosing the right material. In Indiana, where weather can swing from icy cold to humid heat, the material you choose matters for durability, insulation, and long-term value.

At A&N Garage Door Services, we help you choose between the most popular options: steel vs. wood garage doors. Here’s how to decide what’s best for your home or commercial property.

🔩 Steel Garage Doors: Durable, Affordable & Low-Maintenance

Steel is one of the most common choices in Indiana—and for good reason:

✅ Pros:

• Weather-Resistant: Handles rain, snow, and heat with ease

• Durable: Doesn’t crack, warp, or rot like wood

• Affordable: Budget-friendly for homeowners and business owners

• Low-Maintenance: A quick rinse keeps it looking great

• Style Variety: Comes in many colors, finishes, and panel styles

• Insulated Options: Great for attached garages and energy savings

❌ Cons:

• Can dent if hit hard (but we offer dent-resistant models)

• Less “natural” aesthetic than wood

Best for: Busy families, budget-conscious homeowners, and commercial use

🌲 Wood Garage Doors: Timeless Beauty & Custom Appeal

Wood offers a high-end, classic look that boosts curb appeal instantly. It’s popular for custom homes and luxury builds.

✅ Pros:

• Elegant Look: Natural woodgrain adds charm and character

• Customizable: Can be stained, painted, or shaped to your liking

• Strong: Heavier, solid construction

❌ Cons:

• Maintenance Required: Needs sealing or painting to prevent weather damage

• More Expensive: Higher upfront cost and long-term upkeep

• Less Insulation: Unless reinforced or upgraded

Best for: Homeowners who want a standout, customized door and don’t mind regular upkeep

💡 Still Not Sure? We’ll Help You Decide.

At A&N Garage Door Services, we guide you through the entire selection process. We’ll show you real samples, walk through cost comparisons, and help you decide which door fits your home, lifestyle, and budget best.

🏢 Need a Commercial Door?

For business owners, we typically recommend steel sectional or rolling doors for durability and security. We offer commercial installation all over Indiana.

🎁 Special Offers Available Now

• ✅ Free Estimate

• 💵 $100 OFF your garage door installation

• 🔧 Free Lube & Tune-Up with install

• 🧑‍🤝‍🧑 $50 Referral Bonus

• 🏢 Commercial Door Discounts Available

📲 Book your free consult now:

👉 https://angaragedoorservicesllc.com/contact-us

🏡 Steel or Wood, We’ll Install it Right

No matter which material you choose, your door deserves professional installation. Trust A&N Garage Door Services for high-quality products, expert advice, and local service you can count on.

Our blog: Everything you need to know about your garage door

A&N Garage Door Services: Indiana's trusted source for garage door repair, installation, and maintenance. Get expert advice today!

Back to Blog